1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo Nickel

1937 • United States • 5¢

About This Coin

A famous mint error where over-polishing of the die removed the buffalo's front right leg. One of the most recognizable and valuable error coins in U.S. history.

Specifications

Composition

75% Copper, 25% Nickel

Weight

5 grams

Diameter

21.2 mm

Edge

Plain

Designer

James Earle Fraser

Mintage

Unknown exact number (thousands)

Estimated Values by Condition

Condition	Estimated Value
Poor (P)	$400-600
Good (G)	$600-800
Fine (F)	$800-1,200
Very Fine (VF)	$1,200-2,000
Extremely Fine (EF/XF)	$2,000-4,000
Uncirculated (MS)	$4,000-15,000+

* Values are estimates based on market data and may vary significantly based on specific condition, mint mark, and market demand.

Identification Tips

Look at the buffalo's front right leg - it should be completely missing from the body down. The leg is simply not there, though you can see a faint vertical line where it should be. Check for the "D" mint mark (Denver) below "FIVE CENTS". Beware of altered coins - some people grind down normal 1937-D nickels. Genuine 3-legged nickels show specific die markers and characteristics.

Historical Context

In 1937 at the Denver Mint, a die became damaged and was over-polished to extend its life. This polishing accidentally removed the buffalo's front leg from the die. The Mint didn't catch the error immediately, and thousands were struck before the die was retired. The error was discovered by collectors soon after release. It's now one of the most famous error coins in U.S. numismatics.

Notable Varieties

Only 1937-D Denver mint

Frequently Asked Questions

How can I tell if my 3-legged buffalo is real?

Genuine examples have the entire front right leg missing, not just weak or worn. The belly line extends further than normal. There should be no trace of the leg from body to ground. The "D" mint mark must be present. Altered fakes often show grinding marks or unnatural appearance. Get it authenticated by PCGS/NGC.

What is a 1937-D 3-legged buffalo nickel worth?

Values range from $500 in worn condition to $15,000+ in uncirculated grades. Average circulated examples (Fine-VF) sell for $800-2,000. This is one of the few error coins where even poor condition examples are valuable.